How Niche Directories Actually Make Money (and What Year One Really Looks Like)
Directory sites have a reputation as the boring little cash machines of the internet. Build a list of every X in Y, rank on Google, sell featured spots, collect rent. Some of that is true. A lot of it is screenshots of mature sites sold as a year-one plan.
I build directories and SaaS products, so I wanted the real version: how these sites earn, what the operators themselves have published, and what the first twelve months tend to look like. Every number below comes from the operator’s own words or the site’s own pricing page, checked on November 1, 2026. Where a figure is someone else’s estimate, I say so.
The five ways directories make money
1. Featured listings
This is the classic model. Listing is free, but businesses pay a monthly fee to sit at the top of a category, get a badge, or show up on the homepage.
SaaSHub is the cleanest example. Founder Stan Bright launched its first paid option in September 2019: a featured listing at a flat $99 a month, shown on the homepage and on relevant product and category pages. At the time the site had about 25,000 to 30,000 visits a month, and the stated goal was 100 paying products. An outside analysis in 2023 estimated SaaSHub was past $10k MRR from roughly 108 featured listings, but that’s an estimate from counting listings, not a number SaaSHub published.
The point stands either way: featured listings turn a free directory into recurring revenue, and the math is simple. 100 listings at $99 is about $10k a month.
2. Ads and sponsorships
Once a directory has steady traffic in a tight niche, the audience itself is the product. You sell banner slots, sponsored cards inside the listings, or a logo on every page.
OpenAlternative, a directory of open source alternatives to commercial software, shows how far this goes. Its current advertise page lists three monthly tiers: $147, $297 and $597, with the top tier promising roughly 650,000 impressions a month. The same page reports about 220,000 monthly visitors and 900,000 pageviews. According to founder Piotr Kulpinski, ads and sponsorships make up about 65% of the site’s revenue, with featured listings at $197 a month making up the other 35%.
If you’re not selling sponsors directly yet, display ad networks are the passive version. Frey Chu, who builds local directories, ran a thrifting directory on Mediavine ads. Mediavine’s entry program, Journey, now accepts sites with just over 1,000 sessions, and its main program wants $5,000 or more in annual ad revenue.
3. Pay per post
Job boards are directories where the listing itself is the product. Remote OK charges $299 for a single job post that stays live for 30 days, with bundles that cut the per-post price. This works when the people listing get something urgent and measurable out of it, like applicants.
4. Lead generation
Instead of charging businesses for visibility, you send them customers and charge for the referral. This pays best in high-ticket local services, where one booked job is worth a lot to the business. Frey Chu has pointed to luxury porta potty rentals as an example, a niche where a single rental can run into the thousands.
The catch: lead gen depends on relationships. You have to find the businesses, agree on terms and keep the leads flowing. It earns more per visitor than ads and takes more work than any other model here.
5. Memberships, digital products and affiliates
Some directories charge the visitor, not the business. Nomads.com (formerly Nomad List) earns mainly from membership fees, plus companies advertising on the site. Smaller directories do a lighter version: Frey Chu’s thrifting directory sells a guide to thrift store schedules that brings in about $500 a month on its own.
Affiliate links fit almost any directory where listings point at products people buy. Piotr Kulpinski reported about $500 a month in affiliate commissions across his sites in early 2026.
What year one really looks like
Here’s the honest part. The big numbers you see quoted come from sites that are years old. Year one is mostly building traffic.
Two published timelines are worth looking at.
Frey Chu’s thrifting directory took about six months to reach roughly 1,000 visitors a day. Only then did ads go on, and the first month brought in $1,200. It now makes $1,500 to $2,000 a month from ads, and Frey reports profit margins around 98%, since costs are mostly hosting and email.
OpenAlternative launched in February 2024 after a 48 hour build and got over 100,000 visitors in its first week. Piotr posted a $97 featured listing link early, the r/SelfHosted community pushed back, and monetization was paused for almost a year. In 2025 the site grossed $57,361 and crossed $6k MRR in December. Its current figure is about $6,500 MRR.
So a realistic year one looks like this:
- Months 1 to 6: little or no revenue while you build listings and wait for search traffic
- Months 6 to 12: first ad income or first featured listings, often in the hundreds to low thousands a month
- Year two: the year it can start to look like a business, if the traffic held
You’ll see a range of $500 to $5,000 a month for a small directory’s first year quoted around the web. The most cited version comes from Dirstarter, which sells a directory boilerplate and is run by the same founder as OpenAlternative. It’s a reasonable estimate from someone who has done it, but it’s an estimate, and it comes from someone with a stake in you building one.
Practical takeaways for builders
Pick a niche where someone already pays for attention. Featured listings and sponsors only work if the businesses in your niche have marketing budgets. Software tools, local services and job listings all do. Hobby niches often don’t, which is why they lean on ads.
Don’t monetize before you’re useful. OpenAlternative’s early payment link drew backlash. Frey waited for 1,000 daily visitors before turning on ads. Traffic and trust come first.
Price against the alternative, not against zero. A $99 to $197 monthly featured spot is cheap next to paid search for most B2B tools. Sell it as a customer acquisition channel, not a badge.
Stack two or three models. None of the sites above live on one stream. OpenAlternative mixes ads, sponsorships, featured listings and affiliates. The thrifting directory pairs ads with a digital product.
Budget for a slow year. If you need the income in month three, a directory is the wrong project. If you can build on nights and weekends and let search catch up, the economics get good: low costs, high margins, and revenue that compounds once the traffic is there.
What I’m building
I’m building one now: NYCYouth.guide, a directory of youth programs across all five boroughs. It isn’t fully launched, so I have no revenue to share yet. My plan leans on display ads first, like Frey Chu’s thrift directory, with lead packages for providers next. Paid featured listings wait until the site has real traffic, because OpenAlternative’s backlash over its $97 listings is the cautionary tale. I’ll report back with traffic and revenue once it’s live.
Directories aren’t magic. They’re a slow, patient business with very good margins at the end. The founders making real money from them mostly spent year one building something useful and year two getting paid for it.
Sources
All pages read November 1, 2026.
- OpenAlternative, advertise page (pricing and traffic)
- Piotr Kulpinski, 2025 year in review (Dec 30, 2025)
- Dirstarter, OpenAlternative case study (Mar 25, 2026, updated Nov 1, 2026)
- Piotr Kulpinski, Doubling down on directories to hit $13k/mo (Indie Hackers, early 2026)
- Dirstarter, How much do directory websites make (Jul 22, 2026, updated Nov 1, 2026)
- Stan Bright, SaaSHub’s first paid option (Indie Hackers, Sep 25, 2019)
- Niall Doherty, Two directory sites making $10,000 monthly (Indie Hackers, Jun 20, 2023)
- Remote OK, post a job
- Nomads.com, How does Nomads.com make money
- Side Hustle Nation, How to build a profitable online directory, interview with Frey Chu (Aug 21, 2025)
- Mediavine help center, what it takes to get approved
Written by the builder
SGD Labs is one senior engineer shipping affordable, well-designed SaaS tools solo — no growth team, no seed round. These posts are the running commentary. More about SGD Labs.
Built by the same hands
The products this blog is about — go kick the tires.